1989 Jeep Wagoneer Differentials

Keep Your 1989 Jeep Wagoneer in Top Shape with Quality Differentials

Whether you’re repairing or upgrading your Differential, using high-quality parts is key to keeping your 1989 Jeep Wagoneer looking sharp and performing at its best. At Advance Auto Parts we carry a wide selection of dependable options, including Differential Covers, Differential Bearings, and Rear Differential Cover Gaskets. Whether you’re replacing a damaged part or enhancing your truck’s style and protection, you’ll find exactly what you need to get the job done right.

Top-Rated Differentials from Trusted Brands

Looking for a reliable Differential? We’ve got you covered with options from brands you know and trust like Motive Gear, Dorman, and FELPRO. For example, Motive Gear Differentials start at just $2.99 with an average 4.0 star rating. Dorman and FELPRO offer similar pricing and quality, backed by strong customer feedback. With over 60 reviews and a solid 4 star average, you can shop with confidence knowing other Jeep Wagoneer owners approve.

Competitive Prices and Extensive Inventory

The average price for a 1989 Jeep Wagoneer Differential at Advance Auto Parts is around $210.01, with a range that starts at $1.99 and goes up to $1,390.00. With 236 options in stock from 16 trusted brands, finding the right fit is easy. Popular picks like Oil Drain Plug Differential Plug Chrysler 2008-2000, Head Size, Tapered Roller Bearing Cone, and Replacement Ring Gear Bolt For Model 35, Dana 25, 27, 30 & 44 – 3/8" X 24 start at just $9.99 and offer a great balance of form and function.

Explore Related Parts

While you’re upgrading or replacing your Differential, don’t forget to check out other key components like 4WD Components and Universal Joints. At Advance Auto Parts, we’re here to help you keep your 1989 Jeep Wagoneer in peak condition, inside and out.

Essential 1989 Jeep Wagoneer Differentials

USA Standard Gear – 4340 Chrome-Moly Replacement Axle Kit For ’74-’79 Jeep Wagoneer, Dana 44 With Drum Brakes (Part No.35067)

4340 Chrome-Moly Replacement Axle Kit For '74-'79 Jeep Wagoneer, Dana 44 With Drum Brakes

from

$899.99
Product Features:
  • 30 spline inner and 19 spline outer
  • Fits Dana Spicer 44 in 1974-1979 Wagoneer with drum brakes
  • Includes inner and outer 4340 Chromoly axles and Spicer U-Joints
See More

Yukon Gear – Replacement Ring Gear Bolt For Model 20, Grand Cherokee 35, "Super" Dana 30 & Dana 50 – 7/16" X 20 (Part No.33040)

Replacement Ring Gear Bolt For Model 20, Grand Cherokee 35, "Super" Dana 30 & Dana 50 - 7/16" X 20

from

$3.99
Replacement ring gear bolt for Model 20, Grand Cherokee 35, “Super” Dana 30 & Dana 50. 7/16″ x 20.

Product Features:
  • Ring gear bolt for AMC Model 20, “Super” 35, Dana Spicer “Super” 30 and Dana Spicer 50
  • 7/16″ 20 thread
See More

Omix – Plug; Differential Cover; Dana 30; 92-06 XJ/TJ/ZJ (Part No.16595.95)

Plug; Differential Cover; Dana 30; 92-06 XJ/TJ/ZJ

from

$11.79
Direct OE replacement Jeep parts and accessories built to the original specifications by Omix-ADA.

Product Features:
  • Metal
  • OE Style
  • Direct Fit
See More

National – Shaft Repair Sleeve (Part No.99155)

Shaft Repair Sleeve

from

$38.99
National® has built a reputation as one of the most respected names in the industry. We have offered premium sealing solutions for more than 75 years. Our design team keeps pace with the industry and provides advanced solutions for today’s vehicles.

Product Features:
  • Designed to repair damaged, grooved or worn shafts
  • Durable stainless steel construction for corrosion-free sealing surface that surpasses most original shaft specifications
  • Ideal for a shaft where indications of seal wear, such as tracks or grooves have developed
  • Ultra-thin construction (0.01/0.25mm wall thickness) allows original seal size to be used with minimal additional lip loading
  • Easy to install with removable flange and installation tool
  • Installation tool reduces sleeve distortion and allows for installation without removal from the shaft
See More

National – Bearings (Part No.31520)

Bearings

from

$13.49
Manufactured with premium-grade steel, National taper bearing cups feature crowned raceways to ensure even load distribution.

Product Features:
  • PREMIUM MATERIALS – Precision manufactured using premium-grade steel for outstanding durability and performance
  • SMOOTH ROTATION – Crowned raceways for even load distribution
  • OE-STYLE DESIGN – Engineered to meet OE specifications
  • COMPREHENSIVE COVERAGE – Industry-leading coverage for domestic and import applications
  • RIGOROUS TESTING – Comprehensive testing throughout design and development processes by National engineers for quality you can count on
See More

Yukon Gear – Replacement Standard Open Spider Gear Kit For Dana 30 With 27 Spline Axles (Part No.16073)

Replacement Standard Open Spider Gear Kit For Dana 30 With 27 Spline Axles

from

$155.99
Yukon replacement standard open spider gear kit for Dana 30 with 27 spline axles and with or without quick disconnect. Yukon uses higher quality materials and better techniques than OEM to ensure a longer lasting spider gear set. All components come with a one year warranty against manufacturing defects.

Product Features:
  • Spider gear kit
  • Fit Dana Spicer 30 open differential with 27 spline axles
  • Includes two side gears, two pinion gears, cross pin shaft, roll pin and spider gear thrust washers.
See More

Yukon Gear – O-Ring For Toyota & Dana 44 Zip Locker Seal Housing (Part No.34004)

O-Ring For Toyota & Dana 44 Zip Locker Seal Housing

from

$11.29
Product Features:
  • O-ring for seal housing
  • Fits Dana Spicer 44 and Toyota 8″ and V6
See More

Yukon Gear – Forged Replacement Yoke For Dana 60, Stronger Than Billet, With A 1350 U/Joint Size (Part No.41029)

Forged Replacement Yoke For Dana 60, Stronger Than Billet, With A 1350 U/Joint Size

from

$266.99
Yukon forged replacement yoke for Dana 60, stronger than billet, with a 1350 U/joint size. 3.625″ snap ring span, 1.188″ cap diameter. Outside snap ring. This yoke uses u-bolts. All Yukon yokes come with a one year warranty against manufacturing defects.

Product Features:
  • Fits Dana Spicer 60, 70, 70U and 70HD
  • 29 spline
  • 1350 u-joint size
  • 3.625″ snap ring span
  • 1.188″ cap diameter
  • Outside snap ring design
  • U-bolt style
See More

Yukon Gear – Dana 50 Dana 60 Dana 70 & Dana 80 Roll Pin, 0.225" Dia, For X/P Shaft, 1.87" Lng (Part No.33327)

Dana 50 Dana 60 Dana 70 & Dana 80 Roll Pin, 0.225" Dia, For X/P Shaft, 1.87" Lng

from

$7.99
Dana 50 Dana 60 Dana 70 & Dana 80 roll PIN, 0.225″ DIA, for X/P shaft, 1.87″ LNG.

Product Features:
  • Roll pin for Dana Spicer 50, 60, 70, 70U, 70HD and 80
  • 0.225″ diameter
  • 1.870″ long
See More

Dorman – Ring and Pinion Bearing Installation Kit (Part No.697-104)

Ring and Pinion Bearing Installation Kit

from

$179.99
This differential bearing kit includes all necessary installation components for a differential ring and pinion on certain vehicle years, makes and models.

Product Features:
  • Convenient kit – this ring and pinion bearing installation kit includes all necessary components for a complete repair on certain vehicle applications
  • Related repair – smart to have on hand when installing a differential ring and pinion
  • Durable construction – built for reliable longevity, free of defects in materials and workmanship
  • Trustworthy quality – backed by team of designers and engineers in the United States
See More

Yukon Gear – Dana 25 / 27 / 30 / 36 / 44 / 53 Pinion Nut Washer Replacement (Part No.33163)

Dana 25 / 27 / 30 / 36 / 44 / 53 Pinion Nut Washer Replacement

from

$3.99
Replacement pinion nut washer for Dana 25, 27, 30, 36, 44 & 53.

Product Features:
  • Pinion nut washer for Dana Spicer 25, 27, 30, 44 and 50
See More

Yukon Gear – Replacement Baffle For Dana 60 & Dana 70-U (Part No.33001)

Replacement Baffle For Dana 60 & Dana 70-U

from

$6.99
Product Features:
  • Oil baffle for Dana Spicer 60 and Dana Spicer 70U
See More

Motive Gear – Differential Ring and Pinion (Part No.D35-411)

Differential Ring and Pinion

from

$196.99


Product Features:
  • DANA-35 R/P 4.11 STD
See More

USA Standard Gear – Spartan Spring & Pin Kit, Fits Larger Designs (Part No.17010)

Spartan Spring & Pin Kit, Fits Larger Designs

from

$26.99
Spartan spring & pin kit, fits larger designs.

Product Features:
  • Fits Dana Spicer 60
  • Replacement alignment pin and spring kit
See More

Yukon Gear – Dana 44 Grizzly Locker Replacement (Part No.28001)

Dana 44 Grizzly Locker Replacement

from

$998.99
The Yukon Grizzly Locker is the ultimate in locking differentials for street, off-road, & drag racing. Grizzly Lockers provide 100% power to both tires, while still allowing for disengagement while negotiating turns. The Yukon Grizzly locker is a mechanical locking differential. It features a forged case and 8620 internals for maximum strength. It’s patented design reduces common locker failures. All units assembled in the USA! All Grizzly Lockers are backed by the best warranty in the business! Yukon covers the replacement unit and covers any collaterally damaged parts and associated labor, up to $2,000!

Product Features:
  • Fits Dana Spicer 44 with 30 spline axles
  • 3.92 and up ratio only
  • Patented internal design reduces common locker failures
  • 8620 internals for added strength
  • Assembled in the USA
See More

Yukon Gear – Dana 44 Pinion Gear Thrust Washer (Part No.33281)

Dana 44 Pinion Gear Thrust Washer

from

$4.99
Dana 44, GM55P & 8.2″ GM pinion gear Thrust washer.

Product Features:
  • Pinion gear thrust washer for Dana Spicer 44, GM 8.2″ and 1955-1964 GM passenger car
See More

National – Shaft Repair Sleeve (Part No.99114)

Shaft Repair Sleeve

from

$27.99
National has built a reputation as one of the most respected names in the industry. We have offered premium sealing solutions for more than 75 years. Our design team keeps pace with the industry and provides advanced solutions for today’s vehicles.

Product Features:
  • Designed to repair damaged, grooved or worn shafts
  • Durable stainless steel construction for corrosion-free sealing surface that surpasses most original shaft specifications
  • Ideal for a shaft where indications of seal wear, such as tracks or grooves have developed
  • Ultra-thin construction (0.01/0.25mm wall thickness) allows original seal size to be used with minimal additional lip loading
  • Easy to install with removable flange and installation tool
See More

Motive Gear – Differential Ring and Pinion (Part No.D44-373)

Differential Ring and Pinion

from

$193.99


Product Features:
  • DANA-44 R/P 3.73 STD
See More

National – Bearing Race (Part No.LM501314)

Bearing Race

from

$9.29
Manufactured with premium-grade steel, National taper bearing cups feature crowned raceways to ensure even load distribution.

Product Features:
  • PREMIUM MATERIALS – Precision manufactured using premium-grade steel for outstanding durability and performance
  • SMOOTH ROTATION – Crowned raceways for even load distribution
  • OE-STYLE DESIGN – Engineered to meet OE specifications
  • COMPREHENSIVE COVERAGE – Industry-leading coverage for domestic and import applications
  • RIGOROUS TESTING – Comprehensive testing throughout design and development processes by National engineers for quality you can count on
See More

Yukon Gear – Powr Lok Button Kit For Dana 30, Dana 44 & Chrysler 8.75" (Part No.33536)

Powr Lok Button Kit For Dana 30, Dana 44 & Chrysler 8.75"

from

$67.99
Yukon Ring & Pinion sets give you the confidence of knowing you’re running gears designed for the harshest of conditions. Whether it’s on the street, off-road, or at the track; Yukon ring & pinion sets deliver unrivaled performance & quality. Yukon uses t

Product Features:
  • Powr Lok button kit
  • Fits Dana Spicer 30, 44 and Chrysler 8.75″
See More

Yukon Gear – Zip Locker Bulkhead Fitting Kit (Part No.34000)

Zip Locker Bulkhead Fitting Kit

from

$36.99
Product Features:
  • Bulkhead fitting kit
  • Includes bulkhead fitting, outer fitting and o-ring
See More

Yukon Gear – Powr Lok Drive Belleville Plate For Dana 44 (Part No.16171)

Powr Lok Drive Belleville Plate For Dana 44

from

$41.99
Product Features:
  • Belleville plate, non-splined
  • Fits Dana Spicer 44 Powr Lok
See More

Spicer – Differential Carrier Inner Gear Kit – Dana Super 35 – Trak-Loc (Part No.708184)

Differential Carrier Inner Gear Kit - Dana Super 35 - Trak-Loc

from

$244.99
Demand genuine Spicer. Dana design, engineering, testing and manufacturing processes all work in conjunction with one another to ensure unparalleled performance that non-genuine parts simply cannot deliver.

Product Features:
  • Engineered and tested to ensures aftermarket specifications.
  • Forged to ensure greater strength and increased durability.
  • Everything you need to rebuild your differential case.
  • Each component of a Spicer inner gear kit is engineered to exact Dana specifications.
See More

Yukon Gear – Dana 44 Complete Shim Kit Replacement (Part No.55021)

Dana 44 Complete Shim Kit Replacement

from

$51.99
Product Features:
  • Complete shim kit for Dana Spicer 44
See More

Yukon Gear – Dana 44 Carrier Installation Kit Replacement (Part No.57003)

Dana 44 Carrier Installation Kit Replacement

from

$128.99
Yukon Carrier installation kits are great, low cost kit for carrier changes such as Positraction or locker upgrades. Carrier installation kit for Dana 44 differential. This kit contains carrier bearings, races and shims.

Product Features:
  • Fits Dana Spicer 44
  • Includes carrier bearings and races and carrier shim kit
See More

USA Standard Gear – Steel Spool For Dana 44 With 30 Spline Axles, 3.92 & Up (Part No.59015)

Steel Spool For Dana 44 With 30 Spline Axles, 3.92 & Up

from

$289.99
Product Features:
  • Fits Chrysler Dana Spicer 44 with 30 spline axles
  • 3.92 and up ratio only
  • Provides 100% traction to both wheels at all times
  • Not recommended for street driven vehicles
See More

Motive Gear – Differential Pinion Nut (Part No.379570S)

Differential Pinion Nut

from

$6.99
All Motive Gear products are engineered for their specific application and manufactured in state of the art facilities. All of our products undergo rigid quality control processes to insure proper fit, performance and longevity. Motive Gear products can be found in the winners circle at NHRA, IHRA, NMRA, NMCA, SODA, SCORE, BITD, Ultra-4 and NASCAR events because we offer unmatched selection and quality demanded by racers and their crew chiefs – the same quality and selection demanded by DIY customers and top mechanics. With four warehouses strategically located across North America, most Motive Gear orders arrive within 2-4 days. Win with Motive Gear!
See More

Pro-King – Crush Sleeve (Part No.721A034)

Crush Sleeve

from

$2.99
Pro-King is the leading supplier of transmission and driveline products in the aftermarket.

Product Features:
  • All products are designed to meet or exceed OE quality, form, fit and funtion.
See More

Popular 1989 Jeep Wagoneer Differentials Categories

Most Popular Differential Covers for 1989 Jeep Wagoneers

Enhance your 1989 Jeep Wagoneer with one of the 4 Differential Covers we have in stock, starting at just $67.99.

Yukon Gear – Replacement Chrome Cover For Dana 44 (Part No.32004)

Replacement Chrome Cover For Dana 44

from

$67.99
0.080″ thick Chrome replacement cover for Dana 44.

Product Features:
  • Fits standard rotation Dana Spicer 44
  • Chrome
See More

Yukon Gear – Steel Cover For Dana 44 Standard Rotation (Part No.32319)

Steel Cover For Dana 44 Standard Rotation

from

$129.99
Product Features:
  • Fits standard rotation Dana Spicer 44
  • Steel
See More

Yukon Gear – Aluminum Girdle Replacement Cover For Dana 44 Ta HD (Part No.32110)

Aluminum Girdle Replacement Cover For Dana 44 Ta HD

from

$359.99
Aluminum Girdle replacement cover for Dana 44 TA HD.

Product Features:
  • Fits standard rotation Dana Spicer 44
  • Aluminum girdle cover
See More

Yukon Gear – Differential (Part No.29101)

Differential

from

$271.99
Differential

Best-Selling 1989 Jeep Wagoneer Differential Bearings

Upgrade your Wagoneer with one of our 7 best-selling Differential Bearings, earning an average 4 stars rating across 5 reviews.

National – Bearing Race (Part No.LM501314)

Bearing Race

from

$9.29
Manufactured with premium-grade steel, National taper bearing cups feature crowned raceways to ensure even load distribution.

Product Features:
  • PREMIUM MATERIALS – Precision manufactured using premium-grade steel for outstanding durability and performance
  • SMOOTH ROTATION – Crowned raceways for even load distribution
  • OE-STYLE DESIGN – Engineered to meet OE specifications
  • COMPREHENSIVE COVERAGE – Industry-leading coverage for domestic and import applications
  • RIGOROUS TESTING – Comprehensive testing throughout design and development processes by National engineers for quality you can count on
See More

Driveworks – Taper Bearing Cone (Part No.S-LM-104949)

Taper Bearing Cone

from

$11.99
Value-priced bearing meets all cataloged application requirements.

Product Features:
  • Brand may vary by location
See More

National – Tapered Roller Bearing Cone (Part No.LM501349)

Tapered Roller Bearing Cone

from

$19.99
Manufactured with premium-grade steel, National taper bearing cones feature crowned raceways and rollers to ensure even load distribution.

Product Features:
  • PREMIUM MATERIALS – Precision manufactured using premium-grade steel for outstanding durability and performance
  • SMOOTH ROTATION – Crowned raceways and rollers for even load distribution
  • OE-STYLE DESIGN – Engineered to meet OE specifications
  • COMPREHENSIVE COVERAGE – Industry-leading coverage for domestic and import applications
  • RIGOROUS TESTING – Comprehensive testing throughout design and development processes by National engineers for quality you can count on
See More

FAG US – Cone (Part No.KM86649)

Cone

from

$24.29
With advanced load-carrying capacity and compact design, tapered roller bearings are used in wheel bearings, transmissions, differentials, transfer cases and other miscellanous applications. FAG manufacturers over 100 million tapered roller bearings annually.

Product Features:
  • High-precision and High-quality components used in all KITs
  • Coverage of classic and new high-tech solutions for the best system coverage
See More

National – Bearing Race (Part No.25523)

Bearing Race

from

$19.99
Manufactured with premium-grade steel, National taper bearing cups feature crowned raceways to ensure even load distribution.

Product Features:
  • PREMIUM MATERIALS – Precision manufactured using premium-grade steel for outstanding durability and performance
  • SMOOTH ROTATION – Crowned raceways for even load distribution
  • OE-STYLE DESIGN – Engineered to meet OE specifications
  • COMPREHENSIVE COVERAGE – Industry-leading coverage for domestic and import applications
  • RIGOROUS TESTING – Comprehensive testing throughout design and development processes by National engineers for quality you can count on
See More

FAG US – Cup (Part No.LM501310)

Cup

from

$9.99
With advanced load-carrying capacity and compact design, tapered roller bearings are used in wheel bearings, transmissions, differentials, transfer cases and other miscellanous applications. FAG manufacturers over 100 million tapered roller bearings annually.

Product Features:
  • High-precision and High-quality components used in all KITs
  • Coverage of classic and new high-tech solutions for the best system coverage
See More

FAG US – Cup (Part No.LM67010)

Cup

from

$6.69
With advanced load-carrying capacity and compact design, tapered roller bearings are used in wheel bearings, transmissions, differentials, transfer cases and other miscellanous applications. FAG manufacturers over 100 million tapered roller bearings annually.

Product Features:
  • High-precision and High-quality components used in all KITs
  • Coverage of classic and new high-tech solutions for the best system coverage
See More

Top-Quality Rear Differential Cover Gaskets for 1989 Jeep Wagoneers

Choose a high-quality OEM or aftermarket Rear Differential Cover Gasket for Jeep Wagoneers and enjoy top-notch performance from $11.79.

Omix – Differential Cover Gasket; for Dana 35 (Part No.16502.04)

Differential Cover Gasket; for Dana 35

from

$11.79
Is your Jeep differential cover leaking? Do you need to seal it up after some work? Omix-ADA has the OE quality differential gaskets you need.

Product Features:
  • Rubber
  • Sold Individually
  • OE Style
  • Direct Fit
See More

Yukon Gear – Dana 44 Cover Gasket Replacement (Part No.23006)

Dana 44 Cover Gasket Replacement

from

$12.99
Product Features:
  • Cover gasket
  • Fits Dana Spicer 44
See More

Top Picks for 1989 Jeep Wagoneer Rear Housing Cover Gaskets

Invest in one of our 3 durable Rear Housing Cover Gaskets for your 1989 Jeep, knowing you’re getting trusted brands and expert craftsmanship.

Felpro – Axle Housing Cover Gasket Irregular Shaped 10 Bolt Hole Gasket (Part No.RDS 6629)

Axle Housing Cover Gasket Irregular Shaped 10 Bolt Hole Gasket

from

$7.99
Fel-Pro® gaskets are specifically designed for the repair environment to deliver a reliable seal on even the most troublesome applications. Designed for imperfect sealing surfaces and manufactured with proprietary materials, you can count on Fel-Pro for innovative sealing solutions for the real-world repair environment.

Product Features:
  • Meets or exceeds all original equipment specifications
  • Application specific design to ensure a perfect fit
  • Engineered for the sealing repair environment
  • Validated for fit, form and function
  • Unsurpassed quality you can trust
See More

Felpro – Axle Housing Cover Gasket Oval Shaped 10 Bolt Hole Gasket (Part No.RDS 13089)

Axle Housing Cover Gasket Oval Shaped 10 Bolt Hole Gasket

from

$8.29
Fel-Pro® gaskets are specifically designed for the repair environment to deliver a reliable seal on even the most troublesome applications. Designed for imperfect sealing surfaces and manufactured with proprietary materials, you can count on Fel-Pro for innovative sealing solutions for the real-world repair environment.

Product Features:
  • Meets or exceeds all original equipment specifications
  • Application specific design to ensure a perfect fit
  • Engineered for the sealing repair environment
  • Validated for fit, form and function
  • Unsurpassed quality you can trust
See More

Felpro – Axle Housing Cover Gasket: Irregular Shaped 10 Bolt Hole Gasket (Part No.RDS 55019)

Axle Housing Cover Gasket: Irregular Shaped 10 Bolt Hole Gasket

from

$8.29
Fel-Pro® gaskets are specifically designed for the repair environment to deliver a reliable seal on even the most troublesome applications. Designed for imperfect sealing surfaces and manufactured with proprietary materials, you can count on Fel-Pro for innovative sealing solutions for the real-world repair environment.

Product Features:
  • Meets or exceeds all original equipment specifications
  • Application specific design to ensure a perfect fit
  • Engineered for the sealing repair environment
  • Validated for fit, form and function
  • Unsurpassed quality you can trust
See More

Differential Oil for 1989 Jeep Wagoneers

Make a smart move for your 1989 Jeep Wagoneer with products all priced from $99.99 to $148.99.

Yukon Gear – Redline Synthetic "Shock Proof" Oil With Positraction Additive – 4 Quarts (Part No.15005)

Redline Synthetic "Shock Proof" Oil With Positraction Additive - 4 Quarts

from

$148.99
Redline Synthetic “Shock Proof” Oil with positraction Additive. 4 Quarts.

Product Features:
  • Includes four quarts of Redline Shockproof oil and one 4oz bottle of Yukon positraction additive
See More

Yukon Gear – Redline Synthetic "Shock Proof" Oil – 3 Quarts (Part No.15000)

Redline Synthetic "Shock Proof" Oil - 3 Quarts

from

$99.99
Redline Synthetic “Shock Proof” Oil. 3 Quarts.

Product Features:
  • Includes three quarts of Redline Shockproof oil
See More

Yukon Gear – Redline Synthetic "Shock Proof" Oil – 4 Quarts (Part No.15004)

Redline Synthetic "Shock Proof" Oil - 4 Quarts

from

$137.99
Redline Synthetic “Shock Proof” Oil. 4 Quarts.

Product Features:
  • Includes four quarts of Redline Shockproof oil
See More

Top-Rated Differential Brands For Your 1989 Jeep Wagoneer

When it comes to finding the perfect Differential for your 1989 Jeep Wagoneer, Advance Auto Parts has you covered with a wide selection of high-quality OEM and aftermarket options from 16 trusted brands. We carry the most popular Differential brands including FELPRO, Dorman, and Motive Gear, and more, all known for their exceptional customer ratings (average brand rating of 4.6 stars) and competitive prices, as low as $2.99. Purchasing a Differential from us here at Advance Auto Parts is a smart move for both you and your 1989 Jeep Wagoneer, providing peace of mind with parts that meet or exceed OEM standards.

Popular FELPRO 1989 Jeep Wagoneer Differentials

If you’re looking for a top-quality Differential for your 1989 Jeep Wagoneer, Advance Auto Parts has exactly what you need with our selection of FELPRO Differentials. We have 3 FELPRO Differentials in stock for this fitment, all known for their durability and precision fit. With prices starting at just $7.99 and an average cost of $8.19, you’ll find the perfect Differential for your needs and budget. FELPRO Differentials for the 1989 Jeep Wagoneer come highly rated, with over 31 customer reviews and an impressive average rating of 4.6 stars. Choosing a FELPRO Differential from Advance Auto Parts is a smart move to ensure quality and value for your vehicle.
Axle Housing Cover Gasket Oval Shaped 10 Bolt Hole Gasket
from $8.29
(12)
Axle Housing Cover Gasket Oval Shaped 10 Bolt Hole Gasket
“Quality seal. Very pliable and fit perfectly.”
Axle Housing Cover Gasket: Irregular Shaped 10 Bolt Hole Gasket
from $8.29
(9)
Axle Housing Cover Gasket: Irregular Shaped 10 Bolt Hole Gasket
“Felpro gaskets are #1 in my book. Awesome products from Felpro, I highly recommend!”

Top-Quality Dorman 1989 Jeep Wagoneer Differentials

For those in search of a high-quality Differential for their 1989 Jeep Wagoneer, Advance Auto Parts offers a great selection of Dorman Differentials. With 3 Dorman Differentials in stock, you can trust you’re getting top-tier parts designed for durability and a perfect fit. Prices for these Differentials start at just $7.99, with an average price of $169.32, giving you a range of options to suit your budget. Backed by over 13 customer ratings and an average rating of 4.2 stars, Dorman Differentials provide both reliability and excellent performance. Choosing a Dorman Differential from Advance Auto Parts is a smart investment in your vehicle’s performance and longevity.
Axle Shaft Kit
from $319.99
(1)
Axle Shaft Kit
“Fit my 2004 Jeep Rubicon with Dana 44 and rear disc brakes perfectly. Retainer was a little tight pressing on. Studs that came were a little short. Ot”
Ring and Pinion Bearing Installation Kit
from $179.99
(1)
Ring and Pinion Bearing Installation Kit
“Working good so far”
Differential Plug, Rubber
from $7.99
(11)
Differential Plug, Rubber
“It’s a plug”

FAQs for 1989 Jeep Wagoneer Differentials

What are the best-selling Differentials for 1989 Jeep Wagoneers?

Out of 236 Differentials that fit 1989 Jeep Wagoneers, the following parts are the top sellers:

What’s the price range for 1989 Jeep Wagoneer Differentials?

The prices of Differentials for the 1989 Jeep Wagoneer range from $1.99 up to $1,390.00 for the most premium parts.

What is the average price of a Differential for a 1989 Jeep Wagoneer?

The average price for Differentials for the 1989 Jeep Wagoneer is $210.01. Keep in mind the variety of part types within our Differential category, where you are likely to find a wide range of prices across a variety of parts and components.

Does Advance Auto Parts sell Differentials for other Jeep Wagoneer model years?

Yes, we carry Differentials for 29 model years of Jeep Wagoneers between 1963 and 2025. The following model years are the most popular for Differential purchases: 1990, 1988, 1987, 1986, 1985, 1984, 1983, 1982, and 1981.

What are the cheapest Differentials for my 1989 Jeep Wagoneer?

The cheapest 1989 Jeep Wagoneer Differentials we carry are:

Does Advance Auto Parts sell Differentials for any other 1989 Jeep models?

Yes. We stock Differentials for 3 other popular 1989 Jeep models. Some of the most popular are 1989 Cherokee Differentials, 1989 Wrangler Differentials, 1989 Grand Wagoneer Differentials, and 1989 Comanche Differentials.

What are the top-rated Differentials that fit the 1989 Jeep Wagoneer?

Based on 60 reviews by customers, our 1989 Jeep Wagoneer Differentials have an average customer rating of 4 stars. These are the highest-rated categories of Differentials for the 1989 Jeep Wagoneer and their top-rated products:

What types of Differentials do you sell for my 1989 Jeep Wagoneer?

As of 11/2/25, these are some of the most in-demand types of Differentials for a 1989 Jeep Wagoneer:

Can I get help with 1989 Jeep Wagoneer Differential orders?

Contact our customer support team by chat or phone, through the help desk page, where you can find instant answers about Jeep Differentials and more.

What is your return policy for Jeep Wagoneer Differentials?

Advance Auto Parts keeps returns simple. For new Jeep Wagoneer Differentials and accessories, your online orders can be returned, in their original condition, within 45 days. For requirements, see the returns page.